9 American Small Cities With Shockingly Low Livability Scores

Youngstown, Ohio
Pixabay/Pexels
Nine small cities score low on safety, jobs, and services, but basics improve fast when towns fund trust, lighting, transit. Soon.

Livability scores roll everyday realities into one number: safety, housing, health access, commute, and how a block feels after dark. Small cities stumble when one weak system drags others down. Job loss shrinks services, parks fray, and confidence follows them out the door. These places are not punchlines; they hold families, grit, and history worth keeping. The point here is clarity, not scorn. Knowing what hurts helps leaders fix it and helps residents rally around the parts still working.

Pine Bluff, Arkansas

Pine Bluff, Arkansas
Roland Klose, CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Years of factory closures thinned the tax base, and crime headlines overshadow steady work downtown. Housing stays affordable, but wages lag and health outcomes trail state marks, which lowers confidence and keeps talent from sticking. Residents point to new small businesses, a stronger campus link, and church networks that still show up. The challenge is stitching safety, jobs, and schools into a stable climb so affordability stops meaning trade-offs. When those pieces align, the river and rail bones can matter again.

Monroe, Louisiana

Monroe, Louisiana
TheLionHasSeen, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Monroe’s costs tempt newcomers, but the bargain arrives with uneven safety and employment that wobbles quarter to quarter. A strong food culture and short commutes help, yet families still watch schools and late-night noise closely. Infrastructure needs patience: drainage that keeps streets open, sidewalks that invite walking, and lighting that calms corners. Locals brag fairly about hospitality and a resilient arts scene. The path forward is boring by design: steadier policing, workforce training, and block fixes that change how dusk feels.

Danville, Illinois

Danville, Illinois
ComRela, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Danville sits at a useful crossroads, yet decades of industrial churn left gaps in retail and services. Health care anchors jobs, but spending leaks to bigger neighbors, starving storefronts that need foot traffic. Residents push for trail links, façade grants, and brownfield cleanups that turn liabilities into parks and housing. Near-term wins are visible: fewer boards, more porch lights, and a downtown that stays open after dinner. Confidence grows when basics improve together and the core stops emptying at five.

Saginaw, Michigan

Saginaw, Michigan
Saginaw Future Inc., CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Saginaw carries the region’s auto history without the payrolls that built it, and neighborhood quality swings block to block. Schools and safety do the same, which keeps families in wait-and-see mode. Riverfront assets are underused, and winter isolation deepens when transit runs thin. Community groups hustle, but durable wins demand predictable funding and smart infill. When code enforcement, small-business lending, and youth programs sync, livability stops hinging on luck and starts riding systems that do not blink.

Flint, Michigan

Flint, Michigan
Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

The water crisis still shapes trust, even as pipe work and testing regain ground. Low home prices and a strong medical campus are real assets, but skepticism meets every new promise. Livability lifts when basics feel guaranteed: clean taps, reliable buses, streetlights that hold, and parks that open on time. Residents keep showing up block clubs, urban farms, school partnerships that meet kids where they are. The way back is relentless maintenance plus visible wins that prove stability is real.

Gary, Indiana

Gary, Indiana
Driven0711, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Gary’s lakefront and rail access could anchor a renaissance, yet vacant properties and thin services complicate daily life. Many commute to Chicago, and that paycheck often leaves town by nightfall. The city needs patient capital for demolition, remediation, and mixed-income housing that adds feet on sidewalks. Success looks like grocery aisles busy at 6 p.m., youth leagues full, and beaches that feel safe all year. A string of small signals open storefronts, clean blocks can move the score fast.

Bessemer, Alabama

Bessemer, Alabama
Rudi Weikard, CC BY-SA 3.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Industrial roots still define Bessemer, but uneven safety and aging housing stock pull scores down. Proximity to Birmingham helps for jobs and hospitals, yet local amenities thin quickly off main corridors. Residents push for code updates, trail spurs, and a tighter small-business ecosystem: coffee, childcare, clinics within a short drive. The fix is practical stabilize blocks, light intersections, and fund youth spaces that keep evenings constructive. Momentum follows visible order, and order invites the next investment.

Youngstown, Ohio

Youngstown, Ohio
Dblcut3, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Downtown reinvented itself, yet neighborhoods beyond the core still feel the steel hangover. Vacant lots and short-term rentals sit side by side, straining trust and sanitation. Universities and hospitals anchor the economy, but on-ramps to those jobs remain narrow. The city’s livability hinges on stronger transit, modern apprenticeships, and a land bank that moves lots quickly to gardeners, builders, and families. When side streets look cared for, metrics move with them, and pride returns block by block.

Albany, Georgia

Albany, Georgia
Michael Rivera, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Albany’s river setting is an asset, but storm risk, health gaps, and limited higher-wage roles dent scores. A proud military and medical presence adds stability; retail and tech need cultivation. Residents ask for safer crossings, calmer traffic, and policing that feels close and fair. Targeted incentives for infill housing and corner-store upgrades can flip daily experience quickly. Make it easy to walk for milk, ride for work, and linger after sunset, and quality rises in ways people feel.

0 Shares:
You May Also Like