10 Forgotten Fortune-Telling Games People Played on Halloween

Kaj Bjurman, Public Domain / Wikimedia Commons
Old Halloween games promised hints of love and luck, using apples, mirrors, bread, and fire to turn nerves into play, into memory.

Halloween once worked like a hinge between seasons. Long before costume parades, households used the night to ask bold questions about love, luck, and the coming year. Candles burned low, kitchens steamed, and simple pantry items turned into tools for reading signs. These games traveled from Irish and Scottish traditions into American towns, shifting with new homes and wider streets. The drama was small, but the meaning stayed close. A circle of friends, a quiet dare, and answers arriving in flicker and hush.

Apple Peel Initial Toss

Apple Peel Initial Toss
chriswoehrl/Pixabay

A pared apple was peeled in one long ribbon, then tossed over a shoulder so the curl could land on the floor. The shape was read for a letter, believed to hint at a future partner’s initial. Ordinary steps became theater. Bright scent, the soft slap of peel on boards, a room holding its breath. If the letter looked real, laughter broke first and a blush followed. If not, another apple waited on the plate. Hope rarely stops at one try, especially when fruit is near.

Mirror Scrying At Midnight

Mirror Scrying At Midnight
Navid Sohrabi/Unsplash

At midnight, a candle and a mirror formed a private stage where patience mattered more than nerve. Tradition promised a face behind the watcher, a beloved or a warning, depending on what steadied in the glass. The ritual asked for stillness that modern rooms fight to give. Slow breath, warm wax, a house humming in its bones. Sometimes nothing surfaced but the fact of being seen by one’s own gaze. That was a message too, a nudge to notice the hope or doubt already present.

Dumb Supper

Dumb Supper
Martijn Hendrikx/Unsplash

A table was set backward and served in silence, courses reversed and chairs pulled quietly to welcome shy spirits. The custom crossed the Atlantic into Appalachia, blending farmhouse rhythm with superstition and turning kitchens into chapels for one night. Guests used glances and gestures only. Some watched doorways for a shadow to join, others counted the small tremors of candlelight. Whether omen or theater, the hush iced memory into shape. Even a spoon on a plate sounded like thunder in that room.

Barmbrack Charms

Barmbrack Charms
Solo Beckett, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

An Irish tea bread arrived with tokens baked inside, each one a quick forecast for the year. A ring meant a swift marriage. A coin promised prosperity. A bean hinted at lean luck, while a twig suggested obstacles that would need patience. In American kitchens the habit folded into holiday bakes where slices became lotteries and crumbs turned into clues. Flour dusted sleeves, stories moved faster than the kettle, and the winning bite felt earned by chance and cheer tucked into warm loaf.

Hearthside Nut Burning

Hearthside Nut Burning
Anna Evans/Unsplash

Two nuts, often hazelnuts, were named for would be sweethearts and placed together on the hearthstone. If they burned steady, affection promised to hold. If they popped apart, trouble likely waited ahead. The charm drew power from small physics. Crackle, glow, a pause before the jump. Names changed, meanings shifted, and sometimes laughter won anyway. Either way, the fire did what fires do. It warmed the room while everyone searched the coals for a sign and argued kindly about what it meant.

Kale Or Cabbage Pulling

Kale Or Cabbage Pulling
Cats Coming/Pexels

In parts of Scotland, blindfolded guests wandered into gardens to pull a stalk of kale or cabbage. The size, taste, and the dirt clinging to roots were read as signs about a future partner’s fortune and temperament. Bitter leaves suggested trial. Sweet ones, ease. Mud hinted at money that would arrive with effort. The joke came free with the message as friends pocketed clods and made bold claims. A thorough rinse restored the greens, and the night kept its mix of prank and prophecy.

Egg White In Water

Egg White In Water
maja7777/Pixabay

A freshly cracked egg white slipped into a glass of water and was left by the hearth to unfurl. As ribbons settled into towers, ships, or rings, onlookers traced futures from delicate strands. The method, called oomancy, asked for patience and low light to work its share of magic. Silence helped the eye commit to a line. Friendly debate handled the rest. A new year could ride in on a curve of albumen, half science, half wish, entirely social in the way opinions softened.

Walnut Shell Candle Boats

Walnut Shell Candle Boats
Antoni Shkraba Studio/Pexels

A walnut shell held a stub of candle and set off across a basin beside other small boats. Courses were watched like lives. Boats that kept a steady path suggested faithful plans. Boats that spun or drifted apart warned of changes that might force a turn. The glow lit faces leaning close, and wax drips recorded every wobble like notes on a score. The charm felt visible and fair. Everyone launched at once, yet each hull met its own current and learned a lesson.

Yarrow Under The Pillow

Yarrow Under The Pillow
Tatiana6/Pixabay

Bundles of yarrow were tied with ribbon and tucked under pillows to prompt a dream that could name a future partner or deliver a clear choice. The herb’s reputation for healing and courage traveled with the practice, merging comfort with curiosity and handing night work to sleep. Morning brought debriefs over bread and jam as dream fragments traded places with teasing. Even without a perfect vision, the ritual offered a frame to ask what the heart already knew and could finally admit.

Apple Bobbing With A Twist

Apple Bobbing With A Twist
Caleb Zahnd, CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Bobbing for apples doubled as an omen that rewarded skill. The first person to bite an apple from the tub was said to marry first, while a clean, quick bite foretold luck in work and travel. The showmanship hid real talent. Timing, breath control, calm under noise. Water flashed, sleeves soaked, and cheers circled the rim. Victory tasted cold and sweet. For the rest of the year that story had a home at every table, polished with retellings until it truly shone.

1 Shares:
You May Also Like