This meticulously restored 1840s Captain’s Row home in Sag Harbor, NY, known as “Pond View”, boasts an illustrious history, with notable owners from the arts and sports world that reinforce its status appeal and historic significance. Perfect for a success- and future-oriented individual, it seamlessly combines period grandeur with flawless modern renovations, offering four bedrooms, three luxury baths, six fireplaces, Viking and Sub-Zero appliances, and radiant-heated spa baths. The captivating architectural style features original 19th-century elements and cedar shingle charm, set amidst lush, manicured grounds with a heated gunite plunge pool and spectacular water views of Otter Pond and Sag Harbor Cove. With a listing price of $3,995,000, “Pond View” promises privacy, prestige, and lavish comfort ideal for visionary living.
Backyard and Patio
A spacious backyard showcases lush green grass ideal for family gatherings and play, bordered by vibrant, well-maintained landscaping and blooming flower beds. The home’s inviting rear façade features shingle siding and a gabled roof, with crisp white trim framing abundant windows and French doors, bringing in natural light. A welcoming patio with a covered seating area offers shade and comfort, perfect for relaxing or socializing. An additional outdoor dining space with benches encourages al fresco meals with loved ones. The layout maximizes functionality for children and adults alike, blending traditional American charm with timeless, family-friendly appeal.
Backyard Patio Retreat
A welcoming backyard patio extends seamlessly onto a lush green lawn bordered by meticulously maintained gardens and mature trees, ensuring privacy and beauty. The space features a small pool or spa surrounded by floral landscaping, creating a tranquil oasis ideal for both relaxation and play. Comfortable lounge chairs and a modern glass side table rest on the rich wood decking beneath a stylish navy-and-white striped awning that offers shade from the sun. Nearby, a charming outdoor seating area shaded by sculpted trees provides a perfect spot for family gatherings, making the space both kid-friendly and suitable for entertaining guests.
Living Room Details
A welcoming living room showcases an elegant blend of traditional and modern design, perfect for families who value both comfort and style. Soft neutral tones on the walls pair beautifully with crisp white trim and large windows adorned in classic drapery, flooding the space with natural light. A plush lavender curved sofa with decorative pillows creates a cozy lounging area, while a patterned area rug adds warmth and texture. The stately fireplace with detailed molding acts as the focal point, flanked by tasteful art and sophisticated gold sconces. A grand piano and a vintage wooden bar cabinet enhance family gatherings and provide opportunities for shared musical moments.
Living Room Design
A bright and inviting living room with a soft, neutral color palette accented by luxurious textures and gold finishes. Large glass-paned doors allow natural light to pour in, enhancing the openness and creating a welcoming atmosphere. The arrangement features a plush ivory sofa topped with geometric navy throw pillows, paired with cozy blush velvet chairs with gold bases. A checkered carpet sets the foundation for family gatherings, while elegant decor, including framed art above the fireplace and tasteful vases, adds sophistication. The space comfortably balances relaxation and style, making it ideal for both entertainment and quiet family moments.
Family Room Corner
A cozy family room corner features a built-in L-shaped sectional upholstered in deep blue, accented with a mix of velvet and embroidered throw pillows. Natural light pours in from large windows, illuminating custom cabinetry and open shelves displaying books, decorative pottery, and personal treasures. Neutral tones on the walls and shelves create a relaxed atmosphere, while a woven area rug adds warmth and comfort underfoot. The acrylic coffee table with brass accents provides a modern touch and keeps the space feeling open. Carefully selected art pieces and a wooden accent chair bring personality and family-friendly character to this welcoming retreat.
Cozy Family Den
A welcoming family den features built-in cabinetry and shelving that frame the space with ample room for books, games, and decorative objects, creating both tidy storage and visual interest. The plush L-shaped sectional in deep navy blue offers plenty of seating for gatherings, reading, or relaxing, with a mix of patterned and solid throw pillows adding texture and warmth. Neutral-toned wood paneling and cabinetry pair elegantly with the woven area rug and muted wallpaper, resulting in a calm, tranquil atmosphere. Soft lighting and smartly integrated furniture make this a perfect, family-friendly retreat for casual lounging.
Kitchen and Dining Area
Bright and inviting, this kitchen and dining space features a seamless blend of rustic charm and modern amenities. Crisp white cabinetry, black stone countertops, and multiple-pane windows flood the area with natural light. Wide-plank wooden floors and exposed painted ceiling beams add warmth, while an elegant vintage chandelier provides a touch of sophistication. The farmhouse-style dining table, surrounded by mismatched wooden chairs, sits atop a patterned rug for a family-friendly, functional gathering spot. A large black hearth with a cozy fireplace anchors one wall, perfect for creating a welcoming atmosphere during meals or family moments. Adjacent, the living room beckons for relaxing together.
Master Bedroom Suite
Spacious and inviting, this master bedroom features a calming neutral palette with soft gray walls and crisp white trim, creating a peaceful atmosphere perfect for relaxation. The plush carpet provides a comfortable surface, while a large bed with an upholstered headboard is accented by a lavender-patterned throw. Built-in closets offer ample storage for family needs, and a decorative armchair beside the fireplace invites quiet reading or conversation. Natural light streams in through generous windows, and the statement fireplace with a beach scene painting above completes the cozy, family-friendly retreat. Functional and serene, this room blends style and comfort seamlessly.
Master Bedroom Retreat
Natural light fills this airy master bedroom, highlighting its soft blue-gray walls and classic white trim. Exposed white beams overhead add a charming, rustic touch, while two large windows provide tranquil views of the outdoors. The iron bedframe, dressed in crisp white linens adorned with pastel floral patterns, creates a serene and welcoming centerpiece. A woven natural-fiber rug covers the floor, offering a cozy space for play or relaxation. Family-friendly features include sturdy, easy-to-clean surfaces and a spacious dresser for storage. Subtle decor, such as the landscape artwork and vintage bedside lamps, complete this peaceful, inviting haven for restful nights.
Bathroom Vanity and Shower
A bright, inviting bathroom features classic white subway tile walls and a walk-in glass shower that offers a clean, open feel. The pedestal sink is framed by a gold-brushed mirror and matching sconces, introducing warmth and sophistication to the crisp palette. Shiplap detailing and a patterned marble floor add a cozy, cottage-inspired touch, making the space welcoming for families. Thoughtful accessories, such as plush white towels and practical robe hooks, enhance comfort and function. A playful black-and-white beach photograph adds personality, while natural light streams in for a refreshing, serene atmosphere ideal for all ages.
Garden Seating Nook
A tranquil garden seating area offers a shaded retreat beneath mature trees, perfect for family gatherings or quiet relaxation. Cozy wooden bench and chairs, all accented with deep blue cushions and a decorative pillow, create a welcoming, comfortable atmosphere. The lush, well-maintained lawn provides a safe play space for children, and the stepping stone path ensures easy access. Flowering hydrangea bushes and a tall green hedge add privacy, softness, and color to the space, while the arrangement encourages conversation and togetherness. Dappled sunlight filtering through the trees enhances the serene, inviting feel of this outdoor haven.
Garden Fountain Corner
A tranquil garden retreat features meticulously trimmed hedges forming a natural privacy wall, framing a graceful three-tiered black fountain nestled in the corner. The grassy lawn is vibrant and well-maintained, with slate stepping stones inviting visitors along a gentle pathway. Soft purple hydrangeas bloom on the left, adding a pop of color among lush greenery and rounded boxwood shrubs. The design emphasizes harmony and order, making this space ideal for family relaxation or peaceful reflection. The greenery and water element create a serene, child-friendly environment for outdoor gatherings and quiet moments alike.
Listing Agent: Marc Heskell – Associate Real Estate Broker of Compass via Zillow
